SelectionThe practical difference between lug and wafer butterfly valves, when dead end service is allowed and how it affects data center piping.
Wafer valves are held between two pipe flanges by the long bolts running past the valve body. Lug valves have threaded holes in the body, so each side of the valve has its own set of bolts. Both seal the same way. The difference is how they are installed and what you can do with them after.
Wafer is lighter, simpler and lower in cost. It suits straight runs where the valve is isolated by other means and there is no need to take apart one side of the pipe while the other side stays live.
Lug lets you disconnect piping on one side while the line stays in service on the other, which is useful at equipment connections like chillers, pumps and heat exchangers. It is also the style used at the end of a line for dead end service, when the rating allows it.
A valve used at the end of a line holds full pressure from one side with nothing downstream. Many lug valves are rated for dead end at a lower pressure than their full rating, or only with a downstream flange attached. Read the cut sheet and put the required dead end rating into the spec.
As sizes get larger, flanged body styles are common. Pratt Industrial's OS series is offered as wafer OS1, lug OS2 and flanged OS3, and the BF series as wafer BF1 and lug BF2.
Say lug or wafer on every valve line of the schedule. If you write only butterfly valve, the contractor chooses, and the choice is usually the lowest price, which may not allow the maintenance you planned for.