ComparisonHow to decide between the two on small and mid size lines, and why butterfly wins at large diameters.
On small branches, ball valves are compact and give tight shutoff with a full port. Many engineers specify ball valves at two inch and below.
As size grows, ball valves get heavy and expensive. Butterfly valves take over, with lower cost, lower weight and simple actuation.
A full port ball valve has very low pressure drop. A butterfly valve has a small but real loss from the disc. Check the Cv when head is tight.
Resilient seated butterfly valves have a replaceable liner or seat in some designs, and fewer parts in the flow path. Ball valves can be more costly to service at size.
Ball valves for small branches and instrument connections, butterfly valves from about two inch up. Write the split into the specification.