Subscribe
Water and Cooling

Chiller Types Compared: Air-Cooled, Water-Cooled and Free Cooling

A chiller makes cold water to carry heat out of a data hall. The main types differ in water use, power use, space and how well they suit a climate.

Key takeaways

  • Air-cooled chillers use no cooling tower water but often use more electricity, especially in hot weather.
  • Water-cooled chillers are usually more efficient but need a condenser water loop and a way to reject heat, which often uses water.
  • Free cooling uses cool outdoor conditions to cut chiller work, and how much it helps depends on the local climate.

A chiller is a machine that cools water, which then travels to the data hall to pick up heat. The three common choices are air-cooled, water-cooled, and designs that add free cooling. None is best everywhere. The right one depends on climate, water supply, power cost, space and risk tolerance.

How each type works

Air-cooled chillers

The chiller sends its heat straight into outdoor air using coils and large fans. There is no cooling tower and no condenser water loop. The units usually sit outside, often on a roof or a pad.

Water-cooled chillers

The chiller sends its heat into a second water loop, called the condenser water loop. That loop carries heat to a cooling tower, where some water evaporates and takes heat away. The chiller itself is usually indoors in a plant room.

Free cooling

Free cooling is not a separate machine so much as a mode. When outdoor air or water is cold enough, heat can be rejected with little or no compressor work. Some chillers have a built in free cooling coil. Other designs use a heat exchanger with a cooling tower. Dry coolers, which are outdoor radiators with fans, can also do this job.

The tradeoffs in plain lists

Air-cooled

  • Water: very low on site.
  • Power: often higher, and efficiency drops on hot days.
  • Space: needs a lot of outdoor area.
  • Upkeep: fewer water treatment tasks, but coils need cleaning.
  • Best fit: places with water limits or simple plant needs.

Water-cooled

  • Water: often higher, because towers evaporate water.
  • Power: usually lower for the same cooling.
  • Space: compact machines, but towers and pumps are needed.
  • Upkeep: water treatment, tower cleaning and more equipment to maintain.
  • Best fit: large plants where efficiency matters and water is available.

Free cooling add on

  • Water: depends on the heat rejection method used.
  • Power: can drop a lot during cool or cold hours.
  • Space: may need extra coils or heat exchangers.
  • Upkeep: more valves and controls to keep tuned.
  • Best fit: cooler climates, and designs that run warmer water temperatures.

How to choose

  1. Start with the climate. Look at hot hours and cool hours across a full year, not just the design peak.
  2. Check the water situation. Ask about supply, cost, permits and community concerns.
  3. Check the power situation. Ask about cost, capacity and any carbon goals.
  4. Match the supply water temperature. Warmer chilled water, which liquid cooled systems can often accept, gives free cooling more hours of use.
  5. Think about redundancy. Decide how many units can fail while the hall stays cool.
  6. Consider space on the roof, on the ground and in the plant room.

Mistakes to avoid

  • Picking by first cost alone and ignoring years of power and water use.
  • Assuming free cooling hours without a real weather study.
  • Ignoring noise limits for outdoor fans.
  • Forgetting that a water saving choice can raise power use, and the other way around.

Questions to ask

  • How many hours per year will the plant run in each mode?
  • What is the expected water use and power use at partial load?
  • What is the plan if the water supply is interrupted?

A good comparison puts water, power, space and risk side by side. The answer that balances them for your site is the right one.

A simple worked example

Consider two sites with the same size and the same computing load. The first is in a cool, dry region with limited water. The second is in a hot, humid region with a reliable water supply. At the first site, free cooling may cover many hours of the year, and a dry heat rejection method may keep water use very low. At the second site, free cooling hours are fewer, and a water-cooled plant may save a lot of electricity. Neither answer is wrong. They fit different conditions.

Ask a designer to show a full year of hourly weather and the plant mode for each hour. That one chart explains more than any brochure.

Found this useful? Pass it on.

This article is general information for public education. It is not legal, tax, financial or engineering advice. Rules and conditions differ by location, so check with qualified local professionals. Spot an error? Write to info@datacenteroutreach.com and we will correct it.

Have news, a project or a question?Send a press release, your company details, a data center project or a question. We read everything.
Send it in